FFTastic Won't Read Save File

[Jordan95]

I'm trying to use FFTastic to edit my game save but can't seem to get it to work. At first I noticed that it requires a .gme file. I use the ePSXe emulator which I had configured to use a .mcr memcard. I went ahead and downloaded MemcardRex to convert it to a .gme. My ePSXe is now configured to use it instead of the .mcr and works fine (I can save/load my game when I run my ISO).

But whenever I try to open it with FFTastic I just keep getting these two errors. "No FFT save's found" and "No FFT save slots found in memory save". Yet, when I open it up in MemcardRex I can see my two saves, so I don't understand why FFTastic can't read it.

I've been trying to find answers online and am getting no luck.