New Chinese Valentine's Sprite Contest!!

[jimmyjw88]

Haha. Is the valentine girl good? xD

[Vanya]

Yes!

[jimmyjw88]

Haha. Wow...I never thought of that. Thanks ^^

[mav]

Oh shit, I need more time to write up the verdicts. Sorry bout that.

[Vanya]

I think this has devolved far bellow the point of caring about being late for anything.

[jimmyjw88]

So....Did I win? Hahaha. Kidding ^^

[Kagebunji]

Longest contest ever

[jimmyjw88]

And the least entries, I think ^^

[mav]

Certainly not incentive for me to post my verdicts...especially since no one else has.

[Cheetah]

Certainly not incentive for me to post my verdicts...especially since no one else has.

I already posted my rankings a page ago thank you very much.

[Kagebunji]

Yep, Cheetah did, heh.

[mav]

Hahaha. In that case, I'll get mine out ASAP.

Sorry folks.

[jimmyjw88]

Who are the judges again? Sir Cheetah, mav, Silvas?

[SilvasRuin]

I had thought you guys gave up on waiting for my results a while ago.  I need to remember to post them tomorrow since I was wrong about that.

[SilvasRuin]

My response:

1. Jimmy, the date.  Fit the feel of both, creative, very clean edit, and the guy being attacked was amusing.
2. Jimmy, the tiger cupid.  Fit both sufficiently, creative, and overall a solid looking edit.
3. Tonb3rry, St. Valentine.  Fit Valentines, decent edit though it had a few problems, used some original art (as far as I could tell).
4. Kokojo, Altima.  Decent edit, the heart and flower do not blend in nearly as well as they could, disturbing and amusing.
5. Tonb3rry, Lust.  Fit the themes to some degree, but Cheetah is right, it got worse as you continued.  The boobs are too outlined in the original but are barely noticeable at all in the latest, so you jumped between extremes there.  Overall it has potential, but that potential was not sufficiently met.

[Vanya]

o.O
wow
you
guys
are
dedicated
.

[mav]

5. Tonb3rry, St. Valentine. Well, it fits the Valentine theme pretty decently. It's not as well executed or inventive as some of the others, but it's got some appeal to it.
4. Kokojo, Altima edit. Hilarious edit. While it may not have fit both themes perfectly, Koko did a great job defending his choice. That, and the sheer hilarity of the sprite got it this rank.
3. Tonb3rry, Lust. I was extremely impressed with the original design. The toned down version was so-so, but you can see the effort in this sprite. It's probably the most creative in this competition.
2. Jimmy, the date. I'm a sucker for good-looking sprites, so this one was a clear front runner. The only area it may have lagged in was for meeting the Chinese New Year criteria. Still a fine submission though--I wouldn't mind seeing it completed as a full sprite.
1. Jimmy, Cupid Cub. Hit both criterion on the head, it was designed well, followed the rules, and was freaking cute as hell. Great submission.

There ya go.

[jimmyjw88]

I won. Yay!! Well, by default as not much entries. Hehe.
So, did I win any prize? Lol.

[SilvasRuin]

You win the job of finishing both those sprites and getting them in the download section.

[mav]

I second Silvas's motion.